A lot of energy is wasted around discussing the market levels. Short of buying an index, I think if you are focussing on a company, the market levels do not matter. If the company is overvalued in your opinion, the market level will not matter and vice versa. So all the decision is around the stock price and its relationship with the intrinsic value.
That said, it is not easy to ignore the noise. In order to so do, I have modified the way I manage my portfolio and track individual stocks. I have done this also to avoid anchoring to the price at which I buy the stock. To read on anchoring see here
The normal tendency is to look at how the stock has done v/s the price at which it was bought. So I used to get pained if it went below the buy price and happy when it went above. That can mislead us – this is how
Suppose the company you bought came out with results which are poorer than expected. You analyse the results and realize your estimate of the intrinsic value is off by 30%. What should you do ? If you are anchored to the purchase price and if the current price is higher, you tend to discount this information and may continue to hold on to the stock, when a good decision could be to sell.
This is how I currently try to avoid the problem –
I maintain a spreadsheet of all my holding with the following columns
Name
No. of stocks
Intrinsic value estimate
Buy price
Current price
Discount to intrinsic value (intrinsic value- current price / current price)
% gain/ loss
I am constantly looking at the discount to intrinsic value number. If the price drops and the discount is more than 50%, I start buying. If the discount is less than 50%, I sit pat.
After every quarterly/ annual results, I review the instrinic value estimates again and update this number. Check the discount again and buy if below 50%. In addition if I come across some information which I had not considered, I review the instrinsic value again.So the comparison is always to the intrinsic value (which is changing based on new information) and buy/hold or sell decisions are based on the discount to the intrinsic value.
The above ensures that I am not fixated to the current price or market level or what the analysts are saying – Ok I am joking about analysts, I never bother about their opinions (prefer to make my own blunders).
Next post : Adding, selling stocks and adjusting wieghtages
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query anchoring. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query anchoring. Sort by date Show all posts
March 20, 2008
May 15, 2009
Anchoring and a stock sale
In my previous post, I referred to a situation where I started buying maruti suzuki at 500 and when the price started going up, I hesitated and am still waiting to build a full position.
Although any price between 500-600 would have been good, I still ended up getting fixated with the price of 500 and lost a good opportunity. This bias is called as ‘anchoring’. An individual under the influence of this bias gets stuck or anchored to specific value (in this case a specific price) and does not take a rational decision.
So how should one avoid it ? My antidote to this problem is generally to focus on the intrinsic value and have a range of discounts (40-60%) from intrinsic value at which to do the buying. So if we say that maruti suzuki has an intrinsic value of around 1000-1100 , then any price between 450-600 is a good buying point. So, why didn’t I do it ? hmmm still thinking of a good excuse !.
Another mistake I have done in the past is to wait for the price to hit the 50% mark (50% below intrinsic value) and then start buying. The smarter thing to do, would be to buy in a price range.
A sell
I had anaylsed GSK consumer products a year back and had built a small position in it. However as the price never fell below 50% of my own estimate of intrinsic value, I never built more than a token position. The price crossed my estimates of intrinsic value recently and as a result I have closed my position at a decent gain.
The above idea is another example of anchoring where I got anchored to an exact 50% discount to intrinsic value. Finally, my own convicition about the stock has not been high and hence I could never convince myself to build a full position
Being featured
My blog was recently featured as one of the must read 15 blogs in india. A little publicity never hurts :)
In addition, my articles are now being published on some other sites, which you can see on the side bar under affiliations and a few more.
The affiliation with other sites is non financial. I have been aproached by various sites in the past to syndicate or publish my article and if I find the site to be decent, I have agreed to it.
However I have the following understanding with these and any future websites which may want to publish my posts
- I do not and will not write exclusively for anyone
- I will not promote any site on my blog. I will provide a link if required and the readers are free to navigate to the site and use it if they find it good.
- My articles should be published without editing and with due contribution to me
- Complete freedom on what I write.
So you may find articles from this blog being published at other sites too. However I do not have a business relationship with any of these sites. If that were to happen, I will be open and candid in letting everyone know.
Although any price between 500-600 would have been good, I still ended up getting fixated with the price of 500 and lost a good opportunity. This bias is called as ‘anchoring’. An individual under the influence of this bias gets stuck or anchored to specific value (in this case a specific price) and does not take a rational decision.
So how should one avoid it ? My antidote to this problem is generally to focus on the intrinsic value and have a range of discounts (40-60%) from intrinsic value at which to do the buying. So if we say that maruti suzuki has an intrinsic value of around 1000-1100 , then any price between 450-600 is a good buying point. So, why didn’t I do it ? hmmm still thinking of a good excuse !.
Another mistake I have done in the past is to wait for the price to hit the 50% mark (50% below intrinsic value) and then start buying. The smarter thing to do, would be to buy in a price range.
A sell
I had anaylsed GSK consumer products a year back and had built a small position in it. However as the price never fell below 50% of my own estimate of intrinsic value, I never built more than a token position. The price crossed my estimates of intrinsic value recently and as a result I have closed my position at a decent gain.
The above idea is another example of anchoring where I got anchored to an exact 50% discount to intrinsic value. Finally, my own convicition about the stock has not been high and hence I could never convince myself to build a full position
Being featured
My blog was recently featured as one of the must read 15 blogs in india. A little publicity never hurts :)
In addition, my articles are now being published on some other sites, which you can see on the side bar under affiliations and a few more.
The affiliation with other sites is non financial. I have been aproached by various sites in the past to syndicate or publish my article and if I find the site to be decent, I have agreed to it.
However I have the following understanding with these and any future websites which may want to publish my posts
- I do not and will not write exclusively for anyone
- I will not promote any site on my blog. I will provide a link if required and the readers are free to navigate to the site and use it if they find it good.
- My articles should be published without editing and with due contribution to me
- Complete freedom on what I write.
So you may find articles from this blog being published at other sites too. However I do not have a business relationship with any of these sites. If that were to happen, I will be open and candid in letting everyone know.
October 23, 2013
Kill your beloved ideas
I have been
reading a few behavioral finance books on the various biases which impact us as
investors (and in other walks of life too). I have picked up this topic of
study for a very specific reason.
- Do not buy hot stocks. If the media is talking a lot about some hot sector or all my friends are getting into it, I will just avoid it. As a result I did not touch the real estate and infrastructure stocks during the 2007-2008 period and spared myself of a lot of agony
- Do not take stock tips from anyone, especially pretty girls J
Anchoring bias
This is a bias wherein one gets fixated on a variable in the decision making process and uses that to make all subsequent decision. This is a difficult bias to recognize and overcome.
I had been following Crompton greaves limited for some time and decided to buy the stock in 2011 after the company reported poor results in the first quarter. The stock dropped quite a bit after that and I started purchasing the stock as it ‘appeared’ cheaper compared to the past results.
In the case of stocks, investor returns are dependent on future performance, but the data to evaluate that comes from past performance. It is an art, more than science, to evaluate the past results and arrive at an appropriate conclusion. In the case of Crompton, I got anchored to the price and the past fundamentals and did not weigh the state of the industry and management issues more heavily.
How should one avoid this bias? Once you have purchased the stock, it is very difficult to avoid the anchor of the purchase price and past performance. The best approach I know of is to be aware of this bias and constantly question your reason for holding a stock.
This is a tendency to be consistent with one’s behavior in the past. It is a good way to behave in life – if you have been a decent and honest person once, you want to continue and be committed to that behavior.
----------------
Stocks discussed in this post are for educational purpose only and not recommendations to buy or sell. Please contact a certified investment adviser for your investment decisions. Please read disclaimer towards the end of blog.
I have been
analyzing my investment process and am realizing that the weakest link
continues to be the various biases which commonly impact us. If I look back at
the last 15 years of my investing life, I can safely say that I was fluent in
the basics in the first couple of years and could identify good ideas by the
fifth year.
The above
statement would imply that I was an expert by year 5 and poised to be a good
investor. Unfortunately the reality was far from that – you can read my journey
till 2008 here.
Knowing what to do is different from doing it.
Let me list a
few biases and how I was impacted by them. I will also try to explore what one
can do to avoid them
Social proof
This is a
bias where in one is influenced by other investors and the general mood of the
crowd. I wrote about a mistake
I committed a long time ago – purchase of SSI and IT mutual funds during
the dot com boom.
Although I
was new to investing (around 3-4 years), I understood the importance of
valuation and of not overpaying for stocks. Inspite of being cautious for the majority
of my portfolio, I still went ahead and committed 25% of it to IT related
stocks. As I look back, I recall that the main reason was that a few of my
friends were investing heavily in this sector (and getting rich). In addition
to this, a nice and pretty broker also recommended a few hot mutual funds (such
as ICICI technology fund) which were sure to make me rich in a few years.
How could I miss?
I managed to
lose 80% of my capital in a short period of six months. This was unmistakable
evidence that I had made a spectacularly wrong decision. Ever since then, I
have followed a few simple rules to avoid getting influenced by the crowd- Do not buy hot stocks. If the media is talking a lot about some hot sector or all my friends are getting into it, I will just avoid it. As a result I did not touch the real estate and infrastructure stocks during the 2007-2008 period and spared myself of a lot of agony
- Do not take stock tips from anyone, especially pretty girls J
Anchoring bias
This is a bias wherein one gets fixated on a variable in the decision making process and uses that to make all subsequent decision. This is a difficult bias to recognize and overcome.
I had been following Crompton greaves limited for some time and decided to buy the stock in 2011 after the company reported poor results in the first quarter. The stock dropped quite a bit after that and I started purchasing the stock as it ‘appeared’ cheaper compared to the past results.
In the case of stocks, investor returns are dependent on future performance, but the data to evaluate that comes from past performance. It is an art, more than science, to evaluate the past results and arrive at an appropriate conclusion. In the case of Crompton, I got anchored to the price and the past fundamentals and did not weigh the state of the industry and management issues more heavily.
How should one avoid this bias? Once you have purchased the stock, it is very difficult to avoid the anchor of the purchase price and past performance. The best approach I know of is to be aware of this bias and constantly question your reason for holding a stock.
This is a tendency to be consistent with one’s behavior in the past. It is a good way to behave in life – if you have been a decent and honest person once, you want to continue and be committed to that behavior.
However this
behavior can cause a lot of trouble for an investor. Once you have purchased a stock, there is a
tendency to be committed to it and as a result one tends to underweight any
negative information about the company.
Look at any
stock boards – majority of the investors are talking about the positives of the
company. If you are already invested in the company, does it make sense to find
any additional information which just confirms your belief? How will that
benefit your decision?
I have
suffered from the same bias and I can’t think an easy way to avoid it. I have
purchased value traps like Cheviot
Company and held onto them even though the company continues to deliver mediocre
performance and the stock price was stagnant.
The approach
I take now is to rank all the companies in my portfolio in a descending order
of attractiveness. This forces me evaluate more idea more objectively. Once I
have my rank, I compare any new idea with the last idea in the list. If the new
idea is better than the last one on the list, it gets replaced.
The title of
this post comes from the concept of Darwinian selection – kill the weakest
ideas to make way for the stronger one. This also reduces the impact of the
commitment and consistent bias.
I plan to
cover additional biases such as the authority bias, availability bias and more
in the subsequent posts. ----------------
Stocks discussed in this post are for educational purpose only and not recommendations to buy or sell. Please contact a certified investment adviser for your investment decisions. Please read disclaimer towards the end of blog.
September 28, 2007
Sell half and play with the profit ?
Scenario: I bought a stock for Rs 50. My intrinsic value estimate was Rs 100. The stock quickly doubled and then some more. It quotes at Rs 125 now. What should I do?
The most common response I read and have also heard from friends is this – Sell half your holding and recover your investment. What you leave behind is your profit. Let it be in the market as can afford to play around with it.
I have myself engaged in the above logic. However I find this logic completely faulty. My ‘investment’ now is not Rs 50. It is Rs 125. That is the money I have now with me. I can sell the stock completely and choose to invest the money in another security or maybe just buy a Flat screen TV or whatever I fancy :)
The above is a case of anchoring bias. We tend to anchor our thinking to the purchase price of the stock. The purchase price is history. The current price is what matters
Lets take another case
I buy a stock for Rs 50. My intrinsic value estimate is Rs 100. The stock drops to 40. I investigate and realise that I have made an error and the intrinsic value is actually 35 only. What should I do?
The price of 50 now has no meaning. The stock has dropped and is still quoting above the intrinsic value. A rational response would be to take a loss and move on. Before I sound any more preachy, let me tell you I have been guilty of the same thought process. I bought SSI at Rs 1900 and rode it right to Rs 100.
Personally, I think the most rational approach is to constantly evaluate the stock price with your conservative estimate of intrinsic value. If the stock sells for more than intrinsic value , sell or else hold. Nothing else matters! not the price paid for the stock or the current level of the market.
The most common response I read and have also heard from friends is this – Sell half your holding and recover your investment. What you leave behind is your profit. Let it be in the market as can afford to play around with it.
I have myself engaged in the above logic. However I find this logic completely faulty. My ‘investment’ now is not Rs 50. It is Rs 125. That is the money I have now with me. I can sell the stock completely and choose to invest the money in another security or maybe just buy a Flat screen TV or whatever I fancy :)
The above is a case of anchoring bias. We tend to anchor our thinking to the purchase price of the stock. The purchase price is history. The current price is what matters
Lets take another case
I buy a stock for Rs 50. My intrinsic value estimate is Rs 100. The stock drops to 40. I investigate and realise that I have made an error and the intrinsic value is actually 35 only. What should I do?
The price of 50 now has no meaning. The stock has dropped and is still quoting above the intrinsic value. A rational response would be to take a loss and move on. Before I sound any more preachy, let me tell you I have been guilty of the same thought process. I bought SSI at Rs 1900 and rode it right to Rs 100.
Personally, I think the most rational approach is to constantly evaluate the stock price with your conservative estimate of intrinsic value. If the stock sells for more than intrinsic value , sell or else hold. Nothing else matters! not the price paid for the stock or the current level of the market.
September 4, 2007
Book notes – Way of the Turtle - I
I can definitely say that this is a good book and anyone wanting to learn about trading or wanting to evaluate a trading system (in a book or being sold by someone) should read this book. What follows over this and the next few posts is my own summary (not review) of the book with my own thoughts and comments (which I cannot resist putting :) )
The book is written by curtis faith who was one of the turtles (traders) recruited by richard dennis and william eckhardt as a part of an experiment that trading can be taught. The author was one of the original recruits (and probably one of the most successful) who made more than 30 million for Richard.
The book describes the difference between an investor and a trader. An investor buys stocks, but is really buying an underlying business. A trader in contrast is concerned only about price and is essentially buying and selling risk. The second chapter of the books talks of the turtle mind, which I think is equally relevant for an investor.
As we all know that markets are populated by individuals who are driven by fear, greed and all other cognitive biases, which create opportunities for a trader. The book refers to various biases such as loss aversion – higher preference to avoid losses over gains, sunk cost effects – tendency to treat money that has already been committed as more valuable than money to be spent in the future, disposition effect – tendency to lock in gains and ride losses, outcome bias – tendency to judge a decision by the outcome than by the quality of the decision at the time it was made and several other biases such as recency biases, anchoring etc.
The second chapter describes each of these biases in detail and how it affects a trader. The chapter continues with various trading styles such as trend following, counter-trend trading, swing trading and day trading.
One the key points I realised from the initial chapter was that each of these trading styles are valid for specific types of market. Curtis refers to various markets such as stable and quiet, stable and volatile, trending and quiet and trending and volatile. For example, trend followers love markets that are trending and quiet where they can make more money than a volatile market which is more punishing to trend followers. In contrast counter-trend traders love markets that are stable and volatile.
Another key learning for me in the chapter – successful traders never try to predict the market direction. Instead they look for indications that a market is in a particular state and trade accordingly.
I will be posting the rest of my notes over the next few posts. You can find the author’s blog here.
April 8, 2013
Searching the debris
There are two
numbers I want to highlight
If the company you own comes out with slightly disappointing numbers or if there is whiff of a corporate governance issue, the punishment is brutal.
If you are looking closely at the carnage, you may have noticed that companies with a weak business model or poor corporate governance are getting punished severely. At the risk of sounding insensitive, I would say that is the way markets should work. A properly functioning market should reward companies with sound business models and good managements and punish the wealth destroyers.
A lot of investors, if there any left, are shell shocked with this sudden turn of events. The most common advice is to wait for the uncertainty to resolved. The reality is that the future is never certain – it is just that investors sometimes get optimistic and pay for the illusion of certainty.
The second point to keep in mind is to look closely at the fundamentals of the company. Is the company highly leveraged and with a weak business model? In addition, it is important to avoid companies with corporate governance issues.
The final point is regarding one’s own emotions and conviction. Once you have identified a good idea and believe that the market is being irrational in beating it down, it will require a lot of emotional fortitude to hold onto the stock. One is likely to get a daily dose of negativity via falling stock prices and bad news or reports about the company. It is unlikely that a company with a beaten down price is enjoying great growth and high expectations from the market. One needs to do his or her homework that the current downturn is a passing phase and the stock will give above average returns over the next 2-3 year time frame.
I am currently looking at some of the following companies. This is just a preliminary list and I may or may invest in any idea
A roller coaster ride since 2007 and negative returns since then in comparison to double digit returns in gold and real estate means that if you tell someone that you are investing equities, they think you need to be assigned to a mental institution. It is not easy to be any equity investor these days. However if you look past the gloom, then the current downturn is a decent time to pick good stocks.
----------------
Stocks discussed in this post are for educational purpose only and not recommendations to buy or sell. Please contact a certified investment adviser for your investment decisions. Please read disclaimer towards the end of blog.
-13% and -15%
This is the
drop in the CNX midcap and CNX small cap index since the start of the year. If
these numbers look troubling, they don’t even represent the vertical drop in
some stocks. I wrote about some such stocks in this
post and now that seems to have become a daily affair with some stock just
dropping like a stone.
I have to be
honest about one thing – I have never seen such bungee jumping in the Indian
markets. In the good old days, the market took its own sweet time to react to
any fundamental or corporate governance issue and as a result an investor had a
lot of time to get off the train wreck.
No such luck
these days!!If the company you own comes out with slightly disappointing numbers or if there is whiff of a corporate governance issue, the punishment is brutal.
The good news
It would take
real optimist to look for any good in this. I am in that camp.If you are looking closely at the carnage, you may have noticed that companies with a weak business model or poor corporate governance are getting punished severely. At the risk of sounding insensitive, I would say that is the way markets should work. A properly functioning market should reward companies with sound business models and good managements and punish the wealth destroyers.
In case you
think I am being insensitive to the plight of a lot of small shareholders, let
me tell you that I have suffered for my poor decisions in the past and some of
my current holdings have got impacted too. The market is not a good place to
discover yourself.
Digging
through the rubbleA lot of investors, if there any left, are shell shocked with this sudden turn of events. The most common advice is to wait for the uncertainty to resolved. The reality is that the future is never certain – it is just that investors sometimes get optimistic and pay for the illusion of certainty.
One can
choose to either wait for the fog of uncertainty to clear up or better yet have
the courage to start digging through the debris to see if there are some gems
lying around.
The first
point to keep in mind is to avoid anchoring to the pre-crash prices. A stock is
not cheap just because the price has dropped by 90% - look at Deccan chronicle
holdings. A large drop in the stock price is a good starting point, but not a
sufficient condition for a bargainThe second point to keep in mind is to look closely at the fundamentals of the company. Is the company highly leveraged and with a weak business model? In addition, it is important to avoid companies with corporate governance issues.
The final point is regarding one’s own emotions and conviction. Once you have identified a good idea and believe that the market is being irrational in beating it down, it will require a lot of emotional fortitude to hold onto the stock. One is likely to get a daily dose of negativity via falling stock prices and bad news or reports about the company. It is unlikely that a company with a beaten down price is enjoying great growth and high expectations from the market. One needs to do his or her homework that the current downturn is a passing phase and the stock will give above average returns over the next 2-3 year time frame.
I am currently looking at some of the following companies. This is just a preliminary list and I may or may invest in any idea
- BHEL
- Infinite computer s ltd
- Manapuram finance
- FAG bearings
- Whirlpool India
- Eros international
- Tata motors
- Canfin homes – thanks to ayush mittal.
A roller coaster ride since 2007 and negative returns since then in comparison to double digit returns in gold and real estate means that if you tell someone that you are investing equities, they think you need to be assigned to a mental institution. It is not easy to be any equity investor these days. However if you look past the gloom, then the current downturn is a decent time to pick good stocks.
----------------
Stocks discussed in this post are for educational purpose only and not recommendations to buy or sell. Please contact a certified investment adviser for your investment decisions. Please read disclaimer towards the end of blog.
July 25, 2009
Maruti suzuki
I have written about maruti suzuki earlier here and here. Maruti recently announced great results, atleast on the face of it.
The results are good, though not spectacular. The company has shown an 18% year on year growth in volume and 25% growth in profit. The QoQ growth is -4% , mainly due to the seasonality of the sales. The company has been able to manage the costs well on yoy basis and reduce them from the previous quarter. The main reduction has been on material costs and elimination of the exchange variation losses.
So I should be doing handsprings and cartwheels ..right ? not exactly. I have written earlier on anchoring and my failure to build a full position in maruti suzuki. So a 200%+ price increase is a simultenaous reason for me to smile and beat myself :)
Bharat electronics
I have writen about BEL earlier here . BEL recently announced Q1 results and reported 180%+ growth in net profits and a 10 fold increase in profits.
I am happy about the results, but not for the reasons you would expect. Let me explain – My key concern with BEL has been that the company has been booking majority of its sales in Q4 and a result was making almost 60-70% of its profit in the same quarter.
Now the company operates in a project kind of business and hence could be booking revenue based on percentage of completion method during Q4. As a result of the skew, the company had built up high recievables and hence higher working capital.
The company seems to be moving away from the above (need to confirm from the annual report) skew which is good as it would help in improving the cash flow and reduce work capital requirements. So the results are good, not due to the growth, but due to the reduction in the skew in the quarter by quarter revenue.
On an overall basis, the core business of the company is fairly immune from the recession and the company should continue to do well.
CRISIL
I have written about CRISIL earlier here. CRISIL reported its quartely results and reported a 17% increase in topline and 12% increase in the bottom line. The offshore research business continued to show growth inspite of the chaos in the international markets.
I am pretty happy with the results in view of the macro conditions in which these results were achieved. In addition the company reported a dividend of 25Rs/ share which amounts to a 50% payout. The company management is not hoarding the capital, which is a good thing.
CRISIL is one of the few companies with enormous competitive advantages. I have always wanted to buy this company, but was put off by the steep valuations. During the downturn, I was reading an article on buffett and was struck by a comment – buffett tends to read about companies even if he has no plans to buy the stock. If he likes the company, he mentally files it and waits for the right time when the price is right.
The above comment got me thinking and on going through my notes found my analysis of maruti and CRISIL. After a quick analysis, I decided to pull the trigger.
Moral of the story :) (for me) – be prepared in advance. You never know when opportunity strikes !
I have written about maruti suzuki earlier here and here. Maruti recently announced great results, atleast on the face of it.
The results are good, though not spectacular. The company has shown an 18% year on year growth in volume and 25% growth in profit. The QoQ growth is -4% , mainly due to the seasonality of the sales. The company has been able to manage the costs well on yoy basis and reduce them from the previous quarter. The main reduction has been on material costs and elimination of the exchange variation losses.
So I should be doing handsprings and cartwheels ..right ? not exactly. I have written earlier on anchoring and my failure to build a full position in maruti suzuki. So a 200%+ price increase is a simultenaous reason for me to smile and beat myself :)
Bharat electronics
I have writen about BEL earlier here . BEL recently announced Q1 results and reported 180%+ growth in net profits and a 10 fold increase in profits.
I am happy about the results, but not for the reasons you would expect. Let me explain – My key concern with BEL has been that the company has been booking majority of its sales in Q4 and a result was making almost 60-70% of its profit in the same quarter.
Now the company operates in a project kind of business and hence could be booking revenue based on percentage of completion method during Q4. As a result of the skew, the company had built up high recievables and hence higher working capital.
The company seems to be moving away from the above (need to confirm from the annual report) skew which is good as it would help in improving the cash flow and reduce work capital requirements. So the results are good, not due to the growth, but due to the reduction in the skew in the quarter by quarter revenue.
On an overall basis, the core business of the company is fairly immune from the recession and the company should continue to do well.
CRISIL
I have written about CRISIL earlier here. CRISIL reported its quartely results and reported a 17% increase in topline and 12% increase in the bottom line. The offshore research business continued to show growth inspite of the chaos in the international markets.
I am pretty happy with the results in view of the macro conditions in which these results were achieved. In addition the company reported a dividend of 25Rs/ share which amounts to a 50% payout. The company management is not hoarding the capital, which is a good thing.
CRISIL is one of the few companies with enormous competitive advantages. I have always wanted to buy this company, but was put off by the steep valuations. During the downturn, I was reading an article on buffett and was struck by a comment – buffett tends to read about companies even if he has no plans to buy the stock. If he likes the company, he mentally files it and waits for the right time when the price is right.
The above comment got me thinking and on going through my notes found my analysis of maruti and CRISIL. After a quick analysis, I decided to pull the trigger.
Moral of the story :) (for me) – be prepared in advance. You never know when opportunity strikes !
February 20, 2013
Facing the crash
The midcap
index is down by around 7% since the start of the year and the small cap index
is down by 9% during the same period.
That is quite a drop in a span of 45 days and it still does not
represent the true carnage which has occurred in a few stocks which have
dropped by 20% or more in the span of a few days.
It is easy to preach rationality and follow it during times of rising markets. It is however a different ball game to be rational at a time such as now, when stocks can suddenly drop by 20% or more in a matter of a few days.
Finally, it is important to analyze the fundamentals of the company and try to look at it with a fresh mind after each quarterly result. It is important to avoid anchoring the thought process to the buy price and the original thesis and one should look at the company based on the current price and its future prospects
It is quite likely that things could get ugly before they get better. I personally have no way of knowing the future and my investment approach is not based on getting the short term right. I prefer to look at the 2-3 year prospects of the company and if the company is moving in the right direction, I would rather just buy and hold the stock (or buy more if the stock gets cheaper).
The standard
prescription
The standard
prescription is to follow the fortunes of your companies like a hawk and to buy
and sell the stock based on short term expectations. This approach helps you
jump in and out of stocks and be ahead of the market at all times.
This
prescription works well for highly cyclical stocks such as cement or steel
where one needs to time the buy and sell decision to get above average results.
The same approach is a disaster if applied to companies with above average
economics (high return on capital with good growth prospects) at the hint of
the slightest slowdown
I have
personally paid the price for jumping in and out of stocks based on short
expectations – such as with asian paints and marico (and more). I purchased
these stocks in 2000 and sold them off in bits and pieces from 2006 and
onwards. The opportunity loss in all
such cases has far exceeded the actual losses from all my failed stock picks
I won the
battle (short term), but lost the war (long term).
How to handle
such timesIt is easy to preach rationality and follow it during times of rising markets. It is however a different ball game to be rational at a time such as now, when stocks can suddenly drop by 20% or more in a matter of a few days.
One way to
prevent knee jerk reactions is to avoid checking your portfolio everyday. One needs to turn off the financial channels
and stop tracking the portfolio on a minute by minute basis. I really doubt the
long term returns of one’s portfolio are dependent on any breaking news, which
by the way is generally some useless piece of information
In addition
to the above, one needs to have an appropriate level of diversification in the
portfolio. I general limit each position
to around 5-7% in the portfolio to dampen the volatility. A higher level of
concentration and the associated returns are thrilling when the market is
rising. However during market swoons such as now, the momentum can suddenly
turn and make a lot of individuals nervous. A focused portfolio is of no use,
if you exit your positions at such times.Finally, it is important to analyze the fundamentals of the company and try to look at it with a fresh mind after each quarterly result. It is important to avoid anchoring the thought process to the buy price and the original thesis and one should look at the company based on the current price and its future prospects
What if I am
wrong ?
One certainty
about investing is that you will be wrong occasionally. The super investors are
wrong less often than the less successful ones, but still make wrong bets.
In my case,
if one of my picks crashes or the company comes out with a really bad set of
numbers, the first thing I do is to avoid looking at the company for a few days
– no I am not joking. The reason I avoid looking at the company is to prevent
myself from reacting emotionally and taking a hasty decision. It is quite possible
that I may lose 10-15% more on the position, but overtime I have realized that
a calmer mind helps me in taking a more rational decision.
Once the
panic dies down, I generally try to look at the results and key indicators of
the business and try to see what I am missing (which the market sees). In
several cases, I may conclude that the market is over-reacting and may decided
either to do nothing or even add more to the position. Sometimes though, I have
realized belatedly that I have messed up and that the best course of action is to exit (and
feeling like a fool at the same time).
A few months
later, I will come back to the mistake again and analyse it further to avoid
making the same mistake again (new ones will still happen!)
What next?It is quite likely that things could get ugly before they get better. I personally have no way of knowing the future and my investment approach is not based on getting the short term right. I prefer to look at the 2-3 year prospects of the company and if the company is moving in the right direction, I would rather just buy and hold the stock (or buy more if the stock gets cheaper).
March 17, 2008
Ouch !!
Jan 9th – Mar 17th – Returns = -27% and counting.
There is quite a bit of panic and fear in the markets now. It is amazing what difference 3-4 months can make.
It is easy to get preachy, especially if you don’t have skin in the game. But I am not in that position. My own portfolio shot up like a rocket from september and has come down since then. I have seen worse bear markets in the past where the index just kept sliding down for 2-3 years. Will it happen again now? There are enough forecasters and gurus out there forecasting. I don’t want to add to that noise further.
This is what I am doing .
1. Don’t panic – seriously!!
2. Stop watching the market, your portfolio and CNBC – I am half serious about this. This will only induce more panic
3. Don’t anchor – If you were watching a stock for sometime and it has dropped by 20 - 30% from the peak price, it does not mean that it is cheap. There is no point anchoring on the past price. The stock is cheap only if the current price is at a discount to its intrinsic value. So I would not rush out and start buying blindly just because the market has dropped
4. If you have been analysing and watching stocks for some time, a few stocks maybe dropping below the buy targets. It may be time to start buying. Will the stocks go down further …that’s possible. But if you think the stock is undervalued, I would ignore these fluctuations.
The above suggestions are valid if you have followed a long term investing strategy (where long term is more 1 year) and have not been a trader/ momentum player. For traders/ momentum players I have no suggestion as that is a different game, which I have no clue about.
Beyond this I don’t think there is much to do. Ofcourse I am assuming there is no leverage involved and you can psychologically handle the losses.
As I have said earlier and this becomes more and more evident as time goes by – It is close to impossible to predict the market. So I think no one can say whether the market will go up and start dropping again or resume its rise again. What we can do is to be rational about our investment approach and keep a margin of safety
There is quite a bit of panic and fear in the markets now. It is amazing what difference 3-4 months can make.
It is easy to get preachy, especially if you don’t have skin in the game. But I am not in that position. My own portfolio shot up like a rocket from september and has come down since then. I have seen worse bear markets in the past where the index just kept sliding down for 2-3 years. Will it happen again now? There are enough forecasters and gurus out there forecasting. I don’t want to add to that noise further.
This is what I am doing .
1. Don’t panic – seriously!!
2. Stop watching the market, your portfolio and CNBC – I am half serious about this. This will only induce more panic
3. Don’t anchor – If you were watching a stock for sometime and it has dropped by 20 - 30% from the peak price, it does not mean that it is cheap. There is no point anchoring on the past price. The stock is cheap only if the current price is at a discount to its intrinsic value. So I would not rush out and start buying blindly just because the market has dropped
4. If you have been analysing and watching stocks for some time, a few stocks maybe dropping below the buy targets. It may be time to start buying. Will the stocks go down further …that’s possible. But if you think the stock is undervalued, I would ignore these fluctuations.
The above suggestions are valid if you have followed a long term investing strategy (where long term is more 1 year) and have not been a trader/ momentum player. For traders/ momentum players I have no suggestion as that is a different game, which I have no clue about.
Beyond this I don’t think there is much to do. Ofcourse I am assuming there is no leverage involved and you can psychologically handle the losses.
As I have said earlier and this becomes more and more evident as time goes by – It is close to impossible to predict the market. So I think no one can say whether the market will go up and start dropping again or resume its rise again. What we can do is to be rational about our investment approach and keep a margin of safety
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)